Skip to content
SPD

The Sheridan Review

AI
Visit Website

Flat-fee editorial reviews from $44.95: every author gets editorial notes in two weeks, and only 4–5 star books get a published, quotable review.

Best for: Budget-conscious indie authors who want editorial notes on a finished book and a chance at a quotable 4–5 star review for covers, websites, and Amazon Editorial Reviews

Turnaround Time:14 days
$44.95–$99.95/review
Comparing (0/4)
Verified October 2026
Price in this categoryBudget end
$10
$1k

Cheaper than 5 of 24 tools · this price is per review

Tools at this price point typically fit a Under $300 Stack (Under $300 total).

Details

Review Type
Editorial
Reviews Posted To
Platform Only
Turnaround Time
14 days
Genre Focus
All Genres

Strengths

  • Fee doesn't depend on the outcome: The price is the same for every result, and the site says ratings are never tied to payment.
  • Negative results stay private: Only 4 and 5 star reviews are published. Authors confirm they understand this when they submit.
  • Fast turnaround: Two weeks from confirmed submission. Standard Kirkus Indie and IndieReader reviews take 7–9 weeks and Indies Today up to six weeks, though Readers' Favorite Express also promises two weeks.
  • Upfront about AI use: The FAQ explains how AI is used, which few review services do.

Limitations

  • No track record: The domain was registered on October 20, 2026. As of October 27, 2026, the Recommended Reads page shows only invented example books, and there are no independent reviews of the service.
  • One-editor operation: The only editor is "Dan" (named as founder Dan Ibeling only in the site's structured data), a self-published children's author with a debut novel on the way. No other reviewers or professional editing credentials are listed.
  • Missing policies: The site has no terms, privacy or refund pages (/terms and /privacy return 404), so you can't check the refund policy before you pay.
  • Little credibility with the trade: Reviews aren't sent to libraries, Ingram or trade outlets, so a Sheridan quote carries less weight than one from Kirkus, BlueInk or Foreword Clarion.
  • AI handles the first pass: Authors who don't want AI tools reading their manuscript should look elsewhere.
  • Only successes are visible: Since only 4–5 star reviews are published, the public page can't show how strict the ratings are.

The Sheridan Review is a low-cost editorial review service for self-published authors, launched in October 2026. Every author pays the same flat fee, set by word count. Every book gets a written editorial notes report within two weeks, and only books rated 4 or 5 stars get a published, quotable review. It costs a fraction of established services like Kirkus Indie or IndieReader, but it is brand new and has no track record yet.

What You Get

  • Editorial notes for everyone: 3–5 strengths, 3–5 areas to improve, and a sample of flagged errors and continuity slips.
  • 4★ or 5★ outcome: A 200–250 word review you can quote, a digital star badge, a quote card sized for Instagram and Facebook, a feature on the site's Recommended Reads page (cover, review and buy link), and a list of flagged grammar errors.
  • "Not yet" outcome: No rating and nothing published. You get the notes plus a .docx copy of your manuscript with margin notes and tracked grammar corrections throughout.
  • Human-plus-AI read: A human editor and AI tools go through the manuscript together. The site says a human editor approves every report and makes every rating decision, and AI never sets a rating.
  • Formats: Word (.docx) is recommended. EPUB, PDF and print copies are accepted by arrangement, but they don't get the marked-up file.

Pricing: One flat fee per book, the same whatever the outcome, paid through Stripe checkout. Introductory launch rates are $44.95 (up to 80,000 words), $64.95 (80,001–120,000) and $84.95 (over 120,000). Regular prices of $59.95, $79.95 and $99.95 apply after an introductory period that has no published end date. If you revise and resubmit, it counts as a new submission and you pay again.

Who It's For

  • Authors on a tight budget: The introductory price is about half of Indies Today's $89 review and far below the $139–$750 charged by Self-Publishing Review, IndieReader and Kirkus Indie.
  • Authors who want feedback either way: A book that falls short still gets notes and a marked-up manuscript, not just a rejection or a private bad review.
  • Authors filling an Amazon Editorial Reviews section: The site says its reviews belong in Amazon's Editorial Reviews section, on covers and websites, and in press kits. They should not be posted as customer reviews.

Strengths

  • Fee doesn't depend on the outcome: The price is the same for every result, and the site says ratings are never tied to payment.
  • Negative results stay private: Only 4 and 5 star reviews are published. Authors confirm they understand this when they submit.
  • Fast turnaround: Two weeks from confirmed submission. Standard Kirkus Indie and IndieReader reviews take 7–9 weeks and Indies Today up to six weeks, though Readers' Favorite Express also promises two weeks.
  • Upfront about AI use: The FAQ explains how AI is used, which few review services do.

Limitations

  • No track record: The domain was registered on October 20, 2026. As of October 27, 2026, the Recommended Reads page shows only invented example books, and there are no independent reviews of the service.
  • One-editor operation: The only editor is "Dan" (named as founder Dan Ibeling only in the site's structured data), a self-published children's author with a debut novel on the way. No other reviewers or professional editing credentials are listed.
  • Missing policies: The site has no terms, privacy or refund pages (/terms and /privacy return 404), so you can't check the refund policy before you pay.
  • Little credibility with the trade: Reviews aren't sent to libraries, Ingram or trade outlets, so a Sheridan quote carries less weight than one from Kirkus, BlueInk or Foreword Clarion.
  • AI handles the first pass: Authors who don't want AI tools reading their manuscript should look elsewhere.
  • Only successes are visible: Since only 4–5 star reviews are published, the public page can't show how strict the ratings are.

Alternatives

Indies Today ($89, six weeks or less) is an established, low-cost editorial review service with in-house reviewers and a reviewer directory. Readers' Favorite offers a free review or a $59 Express review and has a long history. If you want trade or library credibility, IndieReader and Kirkus Indie cost more but have recognized names.

More Book Reviews Tools

Showing 3 of 25 alternatives

See all 25 tools

Editorial publication dedicated exclusively to indie and small press books, offering guaranteed 400+ word professional reviews with optional 1-week express turnaround.

Also offers Editorial Reviews

Turnaround Time:
35 days
Best for:
Authors seeking an affordable editorial review with optional professional-grade upgrade tier and social media promotion

IndieReader

$249–$399/review

Professional editorial reviews for indie, hybrid, and small-press authors since 2009 — 350-word minimum, fractional star rating, and author suppression option, starting at $299.

Also offers Editorial Reviews

Higher price than The Sheridan Review

Turnaround Time:
63 days
Best for:
Authors who want a $299 editorial review with IR Approved badge for retail buyers and a suppression option

Professional editorial review service founded in 2008, with four pricing tiers from $139 to $399 and a 7-working-day turnaround on the entry tier — among the most affordable and fastest in the space.

Also offers Editorial Reviews

Higher price than The Sheridan Review

Turnaround Time:
7 days
Best for:
Authors who need the fastest editorial turnaround — 7-day rush option available